This review is based on two grinders I've had here recently, so I can't speak for the pizza. First off, the size of the grinders are GIGANTIC - I couldn't even finish half of the first one, which was the Milano. This grinder was SO good - the chicken and eggplant were nicely crispy and the balsamic glaze added a nice sweetness. The second grinder I ordered a couple of weeks later was the Tuna Fish. I forgot to take a picture, but the portion of the tuna was more than generous and the vinegar added a nice touch. I was honestly impressed with how good the sandwiches were that I already plan on ordering again!

Flawless experience. The food is amazing! I wanted to try out the grinders because I always loved them at pizza shops. Inside is small and is mostly set up for take out. But the service was great! They were quick and let us know how much longer we had to wait. They gave extra sauces as well. The food was the best part though. I would recommend a calzone and Philly cheese steak for sure. Everything was hot and crispy and made to order and I will definitely be making another trip here!

I got the salmon steak and cheese. The bread was definitely fresh it tasted as if it was just baked. The salmon grinder was very flavorful and I added aioli and broccoli to it when I got home. I think it would be really good if spinach as well. It comes with onions snd peppers and they are delicious. I always try to add more veggies to my food when I order take out. It's more of a take out place but you could sit down. I think there were two small tables.

Yumy ben piza gud yummmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmy gud thankz forz the piza tunpik

Was looking to grab a Greek salad, and Turnpike Pizza's Greek Salad Pizza came up as an option. OMG this is amazing. New favorite

So, so, SO many great things to say about Turnpike Pizza. The owners are amazing, and always serving some traditional and innovative Italian food with a smile. Noting that they serve both traditional and new creations is important, because if you're looking to try something new, I'm sure they have it. Their menu is wide - inclusive of salads, sandwiches, pizza of course, pasta, pierogies, nachos and don't even get me started on the desserts whatever you are craving, they are able to satisfy. So happy that Turnpike pizza is a staple in our neighborhood

Turnpike Pizza In Newington CT Is Under New Ownership And Has Really Caught Our Eye! Not Only Are They Dishing Out New York Style Pizzas Made With The Freshest Ingredients- They Have An Entire Menu To Chose From As Well! Breakfast, Lunch, & Dinner- They Have You Covered! I HIGHLY Recommend The Turnpike Frutti Di Mare, The Tortellini Ala Vodka, & Diavola Pizza! Even A Regular Cheese Pizza Is A Must Try! And Save Room For Dessert, That Was Some Yummy Cheesecake & The Cannoli's Were Pure Heaven!

So whatever you may have previously thought of or heard about Turnpike Pizzeria, it's time for a fresh look. As of a few weeks ago, they have new leadership, new food talent and a new menu. I didn't connect with Turnpike when they first opened in Newington and I hadn't been in years, but the recent changes had me curious. I visited this week for lunch takeout, and I'm glad I did. I don't remember having a strong positive opinion of the atmosphere when I last visited under the previous management, but I immediately felt welcome when I walked in this week. They had cool music playing. I was warmly greeted, and the crew took the time to tell me about their new direction and their background. (They share some DNA with Pietro's in Hartford) They also gave me a better view of certain things for my pictures. You don't get much better service for takeout. Turnpike has one long table that could seat about 6 people, but it is more of a takeout or delivery place. They have a counter area with heated slices such as cheese, pepperoni, BBQ chicken and Buffalo chicken. You can order whole pizzas, sandwiches, apps, pasta dishes and entrees. The new entree menu has good looking options. I ordered Chicken Tortellini in Vodka Sauce, and it came with a Garlic Knot and salad. The food was all good. The vodka sauce and marinara that came with the garlic knot were both well executed and tasty. The grilled chicken was cut into long thin strips, and it had good texture and was juicy. The cheese tortellini were good. And the dish was well put together. The garlic knot was more like a garlic fist. It was huge, pillowy and garlic-buttery. Even the salad was a step or two up from what you expect. More vegetables. High quality ingredients. The creamy Italian dressing was good. With one very good experience under this new team, I'm putting Turnpike Pizzeria into my area takeout plans. I encourage people in Newington and neighboring towns to try it. 4.5 Stars based solely on my recent experience with the new team.